What To Expect In Today’s Lending Environment
January 31, 2010
It goes without saying that today we are in an environment where it is extremely challenging for small businesses to borrow money. Despite three consecutive quarters of GDP growth, everyone seems to continue to find reasons to be pessimistic about the economy. The naysayers will point out that GDP growth means nothing without job growth (just like they did after the last recession). They will also say that there has been a considerable of one time hits that won’t spur long term growth like last summer’s “Cash for Clunkers” program or other government spending. It is if an entire segment of our population has decided that each piece of positive news should be struck down immediately, and we should commit to being stuck in a sluggish economy.
All of this negative talk does nothing for our psyche, and only adds fuel to the “anti-lending” fire. The government then blames the banks for not lending, and the banks blame the regulators for being too restrictive about the types of loans they can write. At the end of the chain are all of us small business owners who are struggling to meet payrolls, because we can’t find new sources of capital. No one really seems to understand what the new normal is. We all want to go back to the way it was before the crash, and yet, we all blame the loose credit environment for the mess we are in today. The bottom line is that business owners need to get more creative when raising capital, and they need to be prepared if they are headed off to the bank to get a loan.
Today’s New York Times has a good article on how small business is covering the gap. Recently I learned of a local restaurant owner who needed to raise $70k for repairs to his building. The bank refused to lend him any money so he went to his best customers and offered a prepayment/investment opportunity. If you do find yourself in the position of needing to raise capital, and you plan on heading off to see your local banker, there are some things you need to be prepared for.
1) You will need collateral – In today’s business lending environment banks want collateral. The old standards of machinery, equipment, real estate, inventory and AR just won’t do. They want cash, stocks, and bonds. They want to tie up your personal capital. It seems to me they are creating their own problems when they do this. By tying up the entrepreneur’s liquid assets they prevent that same entrepreneur from accessing those assets to grow their business. This really impacts the business owners ability to take risk and invest.
2) Personal guarantees are the norm – In today’s environment personal guarantees are no longer something that can be negotiated away. The bank wants the business owner to not only have some skin in the game, they want them to have all their skin in the game. This means guaranteeing every loan with personal assets, not an attractive proposition to many entrepreneurs.
3) Real estate is not what it used to be – Many business owners have used the equity in their home or commercial real estate as a source of leverage when borrowing. Although these assets are not viewed as totally worthless by banks today, they are viewed as not attractive. Borrowing against your house to invest in your company is no longer something that can be done easily. So all of these years you thought you were building equity in real estate have been washed away.
4) Personal credit must be spotless – Those bumps in the road from your past can no longer be explained away, your need to have a clean credit history. Banks are no longer willing to take chances on riskier borrowers, they want risk free opportunities. There are not many of those out there.
5) You must make your case – Making the business case for the loan is more important now than ever. If it makes good business sense you need to spell it out for your banker. They are under a great deal of balance sheet pressure, and as a result are doing fewer new deals. In the past banks competed for your business, now you may be competing with someone else to get a loan. Be prepared to make a strong business case, otherwise you make walk away empty handed.
I have been through the lending challenges several times over the last eighteen months as my business partners and I have raised capital for a new acquisition and a real estate expansion. Our expansion opportunity was initially rejected, but then approved after we demonstrated that our business, while down, was improving dramatically. For our SBA 504 loan we had to find an outside party to act as an interim lender, because our bank wanted to keep us under the local threshold for money borrowed. We have proven that it is not impossible to borrow money in today’s environment, but you may swallow a lot of pride and Tums along the way!





